✨ Exfoliators & Peels

iS CLINICAL Active Peel System: A Two-Step Formula Flattened Into One 45-Row List

A $99.00 two-step peel whose retail page declares 53 ingredient rows across two separate panels, while the ingredient index merges them into a single 45-row list - at the all-time high on both price channels, with value for money the weakest of six buyer aspects at 44 percent.

DISPATCH 569  ·  UNITED STATES MARKETPLACE  ·  CAPTURED 14 NOVEMBER 2026  ·  ALL PRICES IN USD  ·  DELIVERY CONTEXT NEW YORK 10001

Editorial finding. The retail page publishes two full INCI declarations: 22 rows for Step 1 and 31 for Step 2, 53 declarations in total. The ingredient index publishes a single 45-row list. The difference is exactly the eight materials shared by both steps - water, propanediol, pentylene glycol, apple fruit extract, 1,2-hexanediol, caprylyl glycol, fragrance and disodium EDTA - which appear once after de-duplication. The Step 1 / Step 2 boundary is lost.

Reading card

This dispatch examines one retail listing at a fixed moment. It places the ingredient evidence and the buyer signal before the commercial evidence, then works outward to the price record and the product photography. Every figure below is a snapshot: price, rank and rating move between captures.

Product: iS CLINICAL Active Peel System, two-step gentle at-home peel system for face Exfoliation  ·  Brand: iS CLINICAL  ·  Category route: Beauty & Personal Care › Skin Care › Face › Treatments & Masks › Facial Peels

At capture: $99.00, no list price published, $89.10 with Subscribe and Save, 4.7 / 5 on 368 published ratings1.


SECTION 01  /  IDENTITY, SPECIFICATION, DECLARED COPY AND PACKAGING

Product information

The listing identifies a iS CLINICAL product filed under Facial Peels. It is sold by Amazon.com and was in stock at capture. The specification register, the marketing copy and the printed pack are three separate surfaces; they are kept separate below because they do not always agree.

1.1 Specification register

Table 1 — Specification fields as published on the retail detail page
FieldValue
BrandiS CLINICAL
Item FormWipe
Skin TypeAll
Product BenefitsExfoliates, hydrates, and rejuvenates the skin. Reduces inflammation, acne, and gives appearance of smaller pores
Active IngredientsSalicylic Acid, salicylic_acid
Item Volume2.9 ml
Number of Items1
Item Weight8.16 ounces
Unit Count15 Count
Size15 Count (Pack of 1)
Product Dimensions6.22 x 2.72 x 3.25 inches; 8.16 ounces
Item model number817244012290
DepartmentUnisex
UPC817244012290 081724401229
ManufactureriS CLINICAL
ASINB099MTF1R9
Best Sellers Rank#29,299 in Beauty & Personal Care; #53 in Facial Peels

1.2 What the listing says

  1. Recommended Uses For Product: At-home advanced exfoliation to treat, hydrate and rejuvenate dry, aged, dull looking skin - without drying the skin.
  2. Allure Best of Beauty 2022 Winner

Manufacturer comparison panel. Step in Regimen 2. Treat | Benefits Exfoliates + Treats | Key Ingredients Extremozymes, Tripeptide-1 | Texture Serum-soaked towelettes | Skin Type All Skin Types | Allure Best of Beauty 2022 Winner

Ingredient field on the retail page: Salicylic Acid, salicylic_acid (Active Ingredients field); full Step 1 and Step 2 INCI declarations in the safety-information block.

1.3 What the packaging says

  1. Two deep-blue retail cartons photographed side by side on a reflective surface.
  2. A 'FIRST IMPRESSIONS' graphic lists TEXTURE: Serum-soaked towelettes and IDEAL FOR: all skin types, blemish-prone skin, rough skin, sensitive skin.
  3. A gradient panel reads 'AGE DEFYING EXFOLIATING RENEWING'.
Evidence folder A — transcription of the commercial surfaces
Table 2 — Commercial claims and where they appear
SurfaceStatement
Retail bullet 1Recommended Uses For Product: At-home advanced exfoliation to treat, hydrate and rejuvenate dry, aged, dull looking skin - without drying the skin.
Retail bullet 2Allure Best of Beauty 2022 Winner
Pack panel 1Two deep-blue retail cartons photographed side by side on a reflective surface.
Pack panel 2A 'FIRST IMPRESSIONS' graphic lists TEXTURE: Serum-soaked towelettes and IDEAL FOR: all skin types, blemish-prone skin, rough skin, sensitive skin.
Pack panel 3A gradient panel reads 'AGE DEFYING EXFOLIATING RENEWING'.
Retail ingredient fieldSalicylic Acid, salicylic_acid (Active Ingredients field); full Step 1 and Step 2 INCI declarations in the safety-information block

SECTION 02  /  DISTRIBUTION, ASPECT SIGNAL AND REVIEW-LAYER COVERAGE

Product rating and buyer sentiment

The listing carries a 4.7 out of 5 score from 368 published ratings. The distribution is reproduced as published, in rounded percent shares2. A rounded zero or near-zero bucket is not proof that no such ratings exist, and on a base of 368 ratings a single new rating moves a bucket by roughly 0.27 percentage points.

Table 3 — Published rating distribution
Star bucketShare of ratingsReading
5 star86%dominant
4 star7%middle
3 star2%middle
2 star3%lower tail
1 star2%lower tail
Top two buckets93%combined 5 and 4 star share
Lower two buckets5%combined 2 and 1 star tail
0 20 40 60 80 100 5 star 4 star 3 star 2 star 1 star 86 7 2 3 2
Plate 01 — Rating distribution Vertical axis: share of ratings, percent; bars in palette order.

2.1 Buyer summary and aspects

Customers find the exfoliant effective, with their skin looking glowy and showing improvement in tone. The product makes skin soft and smooth, with one customer noting immediate texture and tone changes. While some customers consider it worth the price, others find it expensive. The duration receives positive feedback, with one customer mentioning they get two uses per packet.

The aspect rows below are aggregate counts produced by the retail platform, not quotations from named buyers. The positive share is positive mentions divided by total mentions for that aspect3.

Table 4 — Aspect sentiment as published
AspectMentionsPositive shareReading
effectiveness6689%positive
skin appearance2496%positive
value for money1844%weakest in set
skin texture1593%positive
skin dryness1450%split
duration888%positive
duration skin dryness skin texture value for money skin appearance effectiveness 0 20 40 60 80 100 88 50 93 44 96 89
Plate 02 — Buyer-signal reading Horizontal axis: positive share in percent, or number of review-layer items when no aspects were surfaced.

SECTION 03  /  MERGED CHANNELS, CLAIM REGISTER, COMPLETE INCI, LEVEL CLASSIFICATION

Product ingredients

3.1 Channel reconciliation

Three independent surfaces were read for the formula: the ingredient field of the retail listing, a community ingredient index with per-material caution grades, and an ingredient claim and function index with a full ordered panel. They were merged by material name, never by substituting one product for another.

Table 5 — Ingredient-channel reconciliation
ChannelWhat it holdsCoverageConsequence
Retail listingTwo separate INCI declarations22 + 31 = 53 rowsTwo-step formula preserved
Community ingredient indexTwo records, one per step22 + 31 = 53 rowsComposition agrees material-for-material
Claim and function indexOne merged ordered list45 rowsEight shared materials de-duplicated

Reading. The index files these two panels under a variant name containing 'Extra Strength' and 'Brightening System', while the retail listing is titled Active Peel System. The material sets agree, so the panels are used as a composition cross-reference; the name mismatch is disclosed rather than silently resolved.

3.2 What’s inside — claim register

A claim printed with a Not prefix on the source means the claim fails. The register below strips that prefix and stores the outcome separately, so no double negation survives into the reading. A failing claim is never described as “free from”.

Table 6 — What’s inside, with source notes
ClaimOutcomeSource noteReading
Oil-freeYES—upheld
Paraben-freeYES—upheld
Silicone-freeYES—upheld
Sulfate-freeYES—upheld
Fungal-acne-safeYES—upheld
Pore-clogger-freeYES—upheld
Reef-safeYES—upheld
Alcohol-freeNOAlcohol declared at row 2 of Step 1failed
Eu-allergen-freeNO—failed
Fragrance-freeNOContains Fragrancefailed
Cruelty-freeNO—failed
VeganNO—failed

Failed claims (5): Alcohol-free, Eu-allergen-free, Fragrance-free, Cruelty-free, Vegan. The claim matrix is charted as Plate 03. These are class-level flags about declared materials, not dermatological verdicts.

Upheld (YES) Failed (NO) Upheld (YES) Failed (NO)
Plate 03 — Claim matrix outcome Number of claims upheld and failed.
Liked Disliked Mixed or unrated Liked Disliked Mixed or unrated
Plate 07 — Community ingredient sentiment Number of ingredient votes; a weak sentiment signal, not a product verdict.

Community ingredient votes: 25 liked, 13 disliked and 7 mixed or unrated. This is a weak sentiment signal on individual materials and is never treated as a product or safety verdict.

3.3 Ingredients list — complete ordered panel

Position is INCI order, so a material at row 2 matters more than one at row 45. Both numeric ratings are read low-is-safer; EM means unrated, not zero risk. A printed range such as 2-4 means sources disagree and is judged on its upper bound. Percentages inside a name are kept as printed4.

Evidence folder B — complete INCI panel (45 of 45 rows)
Table 7 — Complete ingredient list in INCI order
#IngredientFunctionComedogenicIrritancyIndex safetyCaution level
1WaterSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
2AlcoholAntimicrobialEMEM1Low 0-1
3PropanediolSolventEMEM1Low 0-1
4Saccharum Officinarum ExtractMoisturisingEMEM—Not rated
5Hamamelis Virginiana WaterAstringentEMEM1Low 0-1
6Pentylene GlycolSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
7Citric AcidBufferingEMEM1-2Moderate 2-4
8Salicylic AcidMaskingEMEM1Low 0-1
9Aloe Barbadensis Leaf JuiceSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
10Salix Nigra Bark ExtractSkin ProtectingEMEM1Low 0-1
11Vaccinium Myrtillus Fruit ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
12Citrus Aurantium Dulcis Fruit ExtractMaskingEMEM2-4Moderate 2-4
13Citrus Limon Fruit ExtractMaskingEMEM2Moderate 2-4
14Camellia Sinensis Leaf ExtractAntimicrobialEMEM1-2Moderate 2-4
15Pyrus Malus Fruit ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
16Acer Saccharum ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
17Aminomethyl PropanolBufferingEMEM1-4Moderate 2-4
181,2-HexanediolSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
19Caprylyl GlycolEmollientEMEM1Low 0-1
20MentholMaskingEMEM3Moderate 2-4
21ParfumMaskingEMEM—Not rated
22Disodium EDTAChelatingEMEM2Moderate 2-4
23Scenedesmus Rubescens ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEMEMNot rated
24Butylene GlycolHumectant101Low 0-1
25Lentinus Edodes Mycelium ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEMEMNot rated
26GlycerinHumectant001-2Moderate 2-4
27Imperata Cylindrica Root ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
28MaltodextrinAbsorbentEMEM1Low 0-1
29Citrullus Lanatus Fruit ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
30Lens Esculenta Fruit ExtractSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
31Leucojum Aestivum Bulb ExtractSkin ProtectingEMEM1Low 0-1
32Ascorbic AcidAntioxidantEMEM1Low 0-1
33GlycogenHumectantEMEM1Low 0-1
34Sodium PCAHumectant001Low 0-1
35Succinic AcidBufferingEMEM1Low 0-1
36GlutathioneEMEMEM1Low 0-1
37Tripeptide-1Skin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
38Colloidal GoldAntimicrobialEMEM5Elevated 5+
39SorbitolHumectant001Low 0-1
40PEG-8HumectantEMEM1-2Moderate 2-4
411-Methylhydantoin-2-ImideSkin ConditioningEMEM1Low 0-1
42Sodium LactateBufferingEMEM2-5Elevated 5+
43Xanthan GumEmulsifyingEMEM1Low 0-1
44CarbomerEmulsion Stabilising101-2Moderate 2-4
45DextranEMEMEM1Low 0-1

As printed, in one line: Water, Alcohol, Propanediol, Saccharum Officinarum Extract, Hamamelis Virginiana Water, Pentylene Glycol, Citric Acid, Salicylic Acid, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Salix Nigra Bark Extract, Vaccinium Myrtillus Fruit Extract, Citrus Aurantium Dulcis Fruit Extract, Citrus Limon Fruit Extract, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract, Pyrus Malus Fruit Extract, Acer Saccharum Extract, Aminomethyl Propanol, 1,2-Hexanediol, Caprylyl Glycol, Menthol, Parfum, Disodium EDTA, Scenedesmus Rubescens Extract, Butylene Glycol, Lentinus Edodes Mycelium Extract, Glycerin, Imperata Cylindrica Root Extract, Maltodextrin, Citrullus Lanatus Fruit Extract, Lens Esculenta Fruit Extract, Leucojum Aestivum Bulb Extract, Ascorbic Acid, Glycogen, Sodium PCA, Succinic Acid, Glutathione, Tripeptide-1, Colloidal Gold, Sorbitol, PEG-8, 1-Methylhydantoin-2-Imide, Sodium Lactate, Xanthan Gum, Carbomer, Dextran.

3.4 The two-step declarations as printed

The retail page carries two full INCI declarations and the community index carries two matching records. Reproducing them separately matters: the merged 45-row panel loses the boundary between the three-minute first step and the leave-on second step.

Step 1 — 22 materials

  1. Water/Aqua/Eau
  2. Alcohol
  3. Propanediol
  4. Saccharum Officinarum (Sugar Cane) Extract
  5. Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Water
  6. Pentylene Glycol
  7. Citric Acid
  8. Salicylic Acid
  9. Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice
  10. Salix Nigra (Willow) Bark Extract
  11. Vaccinium Myrtillus (Bilberry) Fruit Extract
  12. Citrus Aurantium Dulcis (Orange) Fruit Extract
  13. Citrus Limon (Lemon) Fruit Extract
  14. Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract
  15. Pyrus Malus (Apple) Fruit Extract
  16. Acer Saccharum (Sugar Maple) Extract
  17. Aminomethyl Propanol
  18. 1
  19. 2-Hexanediol
  20. Caprylyl Glycol
  21. Menthol
  22. Fragrance[Parfum]
  23. Disodium EDTA

Step 2 — 31 materials

  1. Water/Aqua/Eau
  2. Propanediol
  3. Scenedesmus Rubescens Extract
  4. Pentylene Glycol
  5. Butylene Glycol
  6. Lentinus Edodes Mycelium Extract
  7. Glycerin
  8. Imperata Cylindrica Root Extract
  9. Maltodextrin
  10. Citrullus Lanatus (Watermelon) Fruit Extract
  11. Pyrus Malus (Apple) Fruit Extract
  12. Lens Esculenta (Lentil) Fruit Extract
  13. Leucojum Aestivum Bulb Extract
  14. Ascorbic Acid
  15. Glycogen
  16. Sodium PCA
  17. Succinic Acid
  18. Glutathione
  19. Tripeptide-1
  20. Colloidal Gold
  21. Fragrance[Parfum]
  22. Sorbitol
  23. PEG-8
  24. 1
  25. 2-Hexanediol
  26. Caprylyl Glycol
  27. 1-Methylhydantoin-2-Imide
  28. Sodium Lactate
  29. Xanthan Gum
  30. Carbomer
  31. Disodium EDTA
  32. Dextran
Table 8 — Why the lists differ in length
StepDeclared rowsShared with the other stepMaterials unique to the step
Step 122814
Step 231823
Combined declarations53——
After de-duplication458 removed45 unique materials

3.5 Classification and count by level

Every material in the merged panel was assigned to one functional level and one caution level. Functional levels describe where a material acts in the formula; caution levels use the highest published numeric grade across the available rating systems (upper bound of ranges). These are editorial groupings of published numbers, not a dermatological risk score.

Table 10 — Functional-level classification
Level (functional group)MaterialsShare of panel
Skin conditioners and emollients715.6%
Antimicrobials and antioxidants24.4%
Solvents, buffers and chelators613.3%
Botanicals and ferments1533.3%
Acids and exfoliants48.9%
Sensory, fragrance and cleansing24.4%
Humectants and moisturisers613.3%
Peptides, proteins and other24.4%
Emulsifiers and surfactants12.2%
Total45100.0%
Table 11 — Caution-level classification
LevelMaterialsShare of panel
Not rated48.9%
Low (upper bound 0-1)2964.4%
Moderate (2-4)1022.2%
Elevated (5+)24.4%
Skin conditioners and emollients Antimicrobials and antioxidants Solvents, buffers and chelators Botanicals and ferments Acids and exfoliants Sensory, fragrance and cleansing Humectants and moisturisers Peptides, proteins and other Emulsifiers and surfactants Skin conditioners and emollients Antimicrobials and antioxidants Solvents, buffers and chelators Botanicals and ferments Acids and exfoliants Sensory, fragrance and cleansing Humectants and moisturisers Peptides, proteins and other Emulsifiers and surfactants 1/3
Plate 04 — Functional classification of the merged panel Number of ingredients in each functional level.
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Not rated Low 0-1 Moderate 2-4 Elevated 5+ 4 29 10 2
Plate 05 — Caution-level classification Vertical axis: number of ingredients in each caution level.
Acne Fighting Skin Texture Dark Spots Scar Healing Reduces Large Pores Good For Oily Skin Redness Reducing Anti-Aging Reduces Irritation Brightening Barrier Repair Hydrating 0 3 6 9 12 14.16 1 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 4 5 6 12
Plate 06 — Benefits by ingredient count Horizontal axis: number of panel ingredients credited to each benefit.

The largest single finding in this section is carried in the reading notes at the end of the dispatch; the level counts above are the quantitative form of that reading.


SECTION 04  /  CAPTURED LADDER, ALL-TIME PRICE HISTORY, DATED OBSERVATIONS, DERIVED ANALYSIS

Product price

4.1 Price at capture

Table 12 — Price ladder at capture, 14 November 2026, USD
ElementValue
Captured selling price$99.00
List priceNot published on the listing
Saving against listNot published
Subscribe and Save$89.10 (10% below the selling price)
Unit price as printed$6.60 per count
AvailabilityIn Stock, sold by Amazon.com

Unit-price reconciliation. The retail page renders $6.60 per count, which follows directly from the 15-count pack ($99.00 divided by 15). The same page states an item volume of 2.9 ml, about 0.1 fl oz; on that stated fill the implied price is $990.00 per fluid ounce. The two figures use different denominators and must not be compared directly. Value readings in this dispatch use the stated fill, not the rendered per-count unit price.

Table 12a — Manufacturer comparison panel, prices as published in the retail A+ grid
Compared productPublished price
Active Peel System (this product)$99.00
Cleansing Complex$49.00
GeneXC Serum$185.00
Hydra-Cool Serum$108.00

The four figures above are the brand's own comparison grid, not independent market quotes; they are included as printed and are not used to compute value.

4.2 All-time price history

An independent price tracker publishes an all-time summary block with five values per price type. Its chart-window parameters rescale the chart only; the summary is always all-time, so period-specific lows, highs and averages are not obtainable. The column headed Current + on the source is a dated last observation, not a live quote. A dash is no data for that price type and is reported as a finding5.

Table 13 — Price history, transcribed
Price typeLowest everHighest everCurrentAverage
Amazon$61.60 (Nov 25, 2023)$99.00 (Jan 02, 2026)$99.00 (Jun 27, 2026)$89.38
3rd Party New$88.00 (Feb 10, 2022)$99.00 (Feb 14, 2026)-$94.33
3rd Party Used----

Product details from the same record: Id 187967374; Upc 817244012290; Ean 081724401229; Group Luxury Beauty; Category Health and Beauty; Manufacturer iS CLINICAL; Model 817244012290; Locale US; List Price $96.00; Sku B099MTF1R9; Scan 1 month ago; Tracked 1 month ago; Monitoring Feb 10, 2022.

— Amazon and 3rd Party New both peak at $99.00.

— The 3rd Party New low is dated to the first day of monitoring, a common launch-listing artefact.

— 3rd Party Used has no data on any column.

0 20 40 60 80 100 Amazon 3rd Party New 3rd Party Used 61.6 88 99 99 99 89.38 94.33 Lowest Ever Highest Ever Current Average
Plate 08 — Price history comparison Vertical axis: USD. Lowest, highest, current and average by price type; empty cells are gaps.

4.3 Dynamic price reading

Plate 09 joins the dated observations that the record actually publishes. These are isolated points, not a continuous price series: the source exposes no row-per-change history, so the line must not be read as the shape of the price between dates. It is included so the distance between the tracker observation and the live capture is visible.

60 70 80 90 100 Feb 10, 2022 Nov 25, 2023 Jan 02, 2026 Feb 14, 2026 Jun 27, 2026 Nov 14, 2026 61.6 99 99 99 88 99 89.1 Amazon channel 3rd Party New Subscribe and Save
Plate 09 — Dated price observations Vertical axis: USD. Isolated dated points joined for reading; not a continuous series.

Freshness. The Amazon Current is dated Jun 27, 2026 - about 140 days before capture - while the live capture of $99.00 confirms the level. The tracker's last update scan and last tracked both read one month ago.

4.4 Derived analysis

Table 14 — Derived figures (arithmetic on transcribed values, one-decimal rounding)
DerivationInputsResult
Current vs Amazon average$99.00 vs $89.38+10.8%
Current vs 3rd Party New average$99.00 vs $94.33+4.9%
Current vs tracker list price$99.00 vs $96.00+3.1%
Current vs Amazon all-time low$99.00 vs $61.60+60.7%
Current vs Amazon all-time high$99.00 vs $99.000.0% (at the ceiling)
Amazon channel spread$99.00 - $61.60$37.40 / 60.7% of the low
3rd Party New channel spread$99.00 - $88.00$11.00 / 12.5% of the low
Channel average premium$94.33 - $89.38$4.95

Every figure in Table 14 is a derivation. None appears on the source as a published number. Where a column is empty, no derived value was manufactured to fill it.


SECTION 05  /  RETAIL PRODUCT PHOTOGRAPHY, THREE PER ROW

Product images

The three retail product photographs below are presented side by side, three per row. Each is labelled with its source. No buyer-photo tiles rendered on the captured listing, so no buyer photography is reproduced or substituted6.

Table 15 — Retail product photography, three per row
Image 1Image 2Image 3
iS CLINICAL Active Peel System product photograph 1, source: Amazon
Source: Amazon
Two retail cartons for the two-step system on a reflective white surface.
iS CLINICAL Active Peel System product photograph 2, source: Amazon
Source: Amazon
'First impressions' graphic describing serum-soaked towelettes and suitable skin types.
iS CLINICAL Active Peel System product photograph 3, source: Amazon
Source: Amazon
'Age defying exfoliating renewing' gradient panel with the product carton.

SECTION 06  /  SCOPE, EVIDENCE TIERS, ANONYMISATION

Methodology, confidence and limitations

6.1 Method

A United States delivery context (New York 10001) was established before any price was read. Prices are native USD only; no conversion, estimation or range was used. The retail listing was captured as a single snapshot. Ingredient evidence was merged by material name from an independent ordered panel and a community ingredient index; where the community index held no record, that absence is stated rather than filled with a similar product. Claims were resolved from the polarity printed with each badge. Price history was transcribed from an all-time summary block, and all percentages and spreads are separately labelled derivations.

6.2 Confidence

Table 16 — Confidence by evidence tier
TierConfidenceBasis
Specification, price and rating at captureHighRead directly from the captured listing
Full ordered ingredient panelHighThree channels agree
Community caution gradesHighPer-material grades on both steps
Price history summaryHighTranscribed verbatim from the rendered summary
Current price freshnessLow92-140 days old
Buyer aspect sentimentMediumAggregate platform counts
Individual review textNot availableNo review bodies rendered

6.3 Limitations

  1. All figures are a snapshot. Rank, price and rating move between captures.
  2. No individual review text, buyer photograph, reviewer name, handle, identifier or profile link is reproduced. Buyer signal is reported only as aggregate counts and platform-generated summaries.
  3. The ingredient panel is the currently indexed version; regional or batch-level formula differences cannot be ruled out.
  4. Community caution grades are reference material, not a regulatory, compliance or dermatological conclusion. Unrated is missing data, not a rating of zero.
  5. The price summary is all-time only; chart-window parameters do not produce period statistics, and no observation-level change history is published on the free page.
  6. The Current column is a dated last observation. Its staleness is stated in section 4.3.
  7. Relative labels such as “2 months ago” drift between reads and are treated as approximate.
  8. Extreme historical highs dated to the first day of monitoring are usually launch or reseller artefacts.
  9. Only standard water.css presentation is used; charts are rendered with a fixed colour palette and are also present as static inline graphics so the reading survives if scripts do not execute.

6.4 Reading notes

Table 17 — Findings that shaped this dispatch
FindingReading
Two formulas became one listThe retail page publishes two full INCI declarations: 22 rows for Step 1 and 31 for Step 2, 53 declarations in total. The ingredient index publishes a single 45-row list. The difference is exactly the eight materials shared by both steps - water, propanediol, pentylene glycol, apple fruit extract, 1,2-hexanediol, caprylyl glycol, fragrance and disodium EDTA - which appear once after de-duplication. The Step 1 / Step 2 boundary is lost.
Both steps carry fragranceFragrance[Parfum] is declared at row 21 of Step 1 and row 21 of Step 2. The claim index therefore returns not fragrance-free with the note 'Contains Fragrance', and also returns not EU-allergen-free. Both panels are consistent with that verdict.
Alcohol at row 2 against a 'without drying' promiseStep 1 opens with Water, Alcohol, Propanediol and includes Menthol at row 20. The retail bullet says the treatment works 'without drying the skin'. The claim index marks the product not alcohol-free, and the buyer-aspect panel records skin dryness at exactly 50 percent positive over 14 mentions - the only dead-even aspect in the set.
Five failed claims on a luxury-positioned productThe claim matrix returns NO for alcohol-free, EU-allergen-free, fragrance-free, cruelty-free and vegan, while upholding seven others including fungal-acne-safe and pore-clogger-free. The community ingredient index additionally flags colloidial gold at safety 5 and sodium lactate at 2-5 in Step 2.
The weakest buyer aspect is the price, at the all-time highValue for money is 44 percent positive over 18 mentions - the only aspect below 50 percent - while effectiveness is 89 percent over 66 mentions and skin appearance 96 percent over 24. The captured $99.00 equals the tracker's all-time high on both the Amazon and 3rd Party New channels.
A current price that is 140 days oldThe tracker's Amazon Current of $99.00 is dated Jun 27, 2026, while the retail capture is 2026-11-14. The live price is unchanged, but the tracker observation itself is about 140 days stale and its last update scan is one month old.

6.5 Notes

  1. No individual review text rendered on the captured listing; no reviewer name, handle, identifier or profile link appears anywhere in this dispatch.
  2. Star shares are published percentages, not counts. Counts derived from them are estimates and are not used as exact figures.
  3. Aspect sentiment is a machine-generated aggregate; no reviewer identity is attached to any row and no review body is quoted.
  4. Unrated is missing data. No zero was substituted for an empty rating cell, and no average risk score was computed over the few rated rows.
  5. The price tracker publishes no ingredient or INCI field. Its only ingredient signal is the product title; no ingredient list was reconstructed from it.
  6. Retail product photographs were registered as the article's real-photo gallery; no third-party or user-generated image is presented as a product photograph.