✨ Exfoliators & Peels

NUVADERMIS Glycolic Peel Pads: A Disputed 35% Claim and Two Conflicting Panels

A 60-pad glycolic treatment whose 35% headline is openly questioned in the listing's own buyer summary, backed by an 18-item brand declaration and a 28-row independent panel that disagree on the vitamin C form, a retinoid, and four sensory oils - while a four-year price record holds no first-party …

Inspection ticket issued 2026-11-15 for a single US-listed cosmetic SKU. All money is native USD. All figures are a snapshot and may move between captures.



[A] Product information

Identity, shelf position, declared specification and the short reading.

Brand
NUVADERMIS
Full retail title
NUVADERMIS 35% Glycolic Acid Peel Pads - Exfoliating Facial Resurfacing for Blackheads, Dark Spots, and Acne - Safe for Sensitive Skin - 60 Double-Sided Pads
Category route
Beauty & Personal Care > Skin Care > Face > Cleansers
Catalogue rank
#22,675 in Beauty & Personal Care; #661 in Facial Cleansing Products
Format
60 pre-saturated double-sided pads
Price at capture
$19.99
Rating
4.3 / 5 across 1,425 ratings
Declared materials
28 rows in the reference panel; 18 rows in the retail declaration
Channels read
4 (retail listing, price tracker, two ingredient databases)
Line A1. Declared specification
Field Value
Brand NUVADERMIS
Skin Type All
Material Feature Cruelty Free
Unit Count 60 Count
Number of Items 1
Package Dimensions 2.99 x 2.91 x 2.6 inches; 5.93 ounces
Item model number FJFIEJFOK1715
UPC 693634265824
Manufacturer NuvaDermis
ASIN B0B51SR6Z1
Best Sellers Rank #22,675 in Beauty & Personal Care; #661 in Facial Cleansing Products

What the brand states

  • Unlock Smooth & Radiant Skin: Our alcohol-free exfoliating pads feature 35% Glycolic Acid to gently yet effectively unclog pores, enhance complexion, and provide a radiant, exfoliated finish.
  • Enhance Your Skincare Routine: enriched with 35% Glycolic Acid, refine skin tone, improve radiance, and unclog pores. Green Tea offers deep moisturization and calming effects, while Vitamins C & E provide antioxidant protection.
  • Natural Resurfacing for Complete Beauty: ideal for facial and body use; gently remove impurities and improve skin texture on the face, neck, chest, and more.
  • All-Skin-Type Beauty Secret: suitable for all skin types and manufactured in a state-of-the-art facility.
  • Quality You Can Trust: satisfaction guarantee and customer support.

Usage and brand content

Product description: wash and dry affected area, apply one pad to the face, leave on for 2-5 minutes, follow with SPF 30 during the day.

Short reading

Verdict. Two declarations of the same jar disagree on 10 of 28 rows, the headline 35% concentration is challenged in the retailer's own buyer summary, and the lowest-scoring sentiment aspect is 'ingredients' at 33% positive.

Findings in order of weight

  1. The 35% claim is contested by buyers. The retailer's own aggregated summary states that 'several customers note that the product does not contain 35% glycolic acid as advertised'. The 'ingredients' aspect is the weakest of eight at 33% positive (6 positive / 12 negative across 18 mentions). No package image in the gallery prints the 35% figure.
  2. Two panels, two different formulas. The brand's 18-item declaration uses consumer names; the independent database's 28-row INCI uses INCI names. Both put Glycolic Acid at row 2, but the brand names I-Ascorbyl Palmitate as the vitamin C while the database records 3-O-Ethyl Ascorbic Acid at row 8 - two different derivatives. The database additionally lists Retinyl Palmitate (23), BHT (28), four PEG emulsifiers and two synthetic cooling agents absent from the brand list.
  3. 'Safe for Sensitive Skin' meets four flagged concerns. The independent database tags four concerns (rosacea, eczema, dryness, irritation) and marks the formula Not Fragrance-free, Not EU-allergen-free and Not Fungal-acne-safe. The brand's own panel carries Menthol, Eucalyptus Oil and Spearmint Oil, while the database carries Menthol and Menthyl Lactate.
  4. A formaldehyde-releasing preservative pair. Both channels agree on Diazolidinyl Urea and Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate at the tail of the panel - the same preservative system, and one of the few points of agreement.
  5. No first-party price in four years. The tracker's Amazon row is empty for the entire record since Oct 28, 2022. The $19.99 buy box equals the 3rd Party New current value; the tracker's $26.99 list sits 35% above it.

[B] Product rating and buyer sentiment

Published distribution, aggregated aspect sentiment, and the review-text caveat.

Line B1. Rating ledger
Measure Reading
Aggregate score 4.3 out of 5
Rating count 1,425
5 star 67%
4 star 14%
3 star 10%
2 star 4%
1 star 5%
Positive (4-5 star) share 81%
Negative (1-2 star) share 9%
1 star 2 star 3 star 4 star 5 star 0 20 40 60 80 100 5% 4% 10% 14% 67%
Chart 1 of 8. Published star distribution Bars show the share of ratings in each band, 5 star at the top. Shares are published rounded values.

Percentages are published rounded shares, so a small bucket is not proof of zero ratings. With 1,425 ratings, a single rating moves a bucket by roughly 0.070 percentage points.

Retailer-aggregated buyer summary

Customers report that the skin cleaning wipes make their skin feel smooth and glow without over-drying, while being gentle and non-irritating. Moreover, the product receives positive feedback for its appearance and texture. However, customers disagree on its effectiveness and value for money, with some finding it very effective while others report no results. Additionally, several customers note that the product does not contain 35% glycolic acid as advertised.

Line B2. Aspect sentiment ledger
Aspect Mentions Positive Negative Positive share
effectiveness 130 90 40 69%
skin softness 73 60 13 82%
skin irritation 49 37 12 76%
value for money 36 19 17 53%
skin improvement 30 23 7 77%
texture 27 19 8 70%
appearance 18 18 0 100%
ingredients 18 6 12 33%
ingredients appearance texture skin improvement value for money skin irritation skin softness effectiveness 0 20 40 60 80 100 115 33% 100% 70% 77% 53% 76% 82% 69%
Chart 2 of 8. Buyer sentiment by aspect Positive share of mentions for each aspect, computed from the retailer's aggregated aspect counts. A 50% mark is the split point.

Reading. The weakest aspect is ingredients at 33% positive across 18 mentions (6 positive / 12 negative). The largest evidence base is effectiveness with 130 mentions at 69% positive. These are machine-aggregated counts, not verbatim reviews.

Review-text limitation. No individual review bodies and no buyer photographs rendered on this SKU. Consequently no review text is quoted, no reviewer identity appears anywhere in this report, and the qualitative layer above is limited to the retailer's aggregated summary and aspect counts. This is a disclosed gap, not an inference of satisfaction.


[C] Product ingredients

Merged channel coverage, level classification, claim matrix and the full declared panel.

Merged channel coverage

Line C1. Ingredient evidence audit
Channel Rows Outcome
Retail listing declaration 18 rows Consumer-name INCI-style list read from the product page
Community ingredient database A 0 rows Brand not indexed. The channel was reachable; the SKU is not indexed.
Community ingredient database B 28 rows Full INCI with function, comedogenic and irritancy labels; 12 of 12 benefits read

Merge rule. The two databases were merged at row level. Database A contributes zero rows for this SKU, so the merged panel is carried by database B and cross-checked against the retail declaration. The level classification below is computed on the merged 28-row panel, assigning each material to exactly one of seven functional levels from its database function label with explicit name overrides for solvents, preservatives, acids and sensory agents. No ingredient is double-counted.

Channel agreement. The retail declaration lists 18 materials and database B lists 28. They are not the same list: the retail declaration uses consumer names and omits or substitutes several materials that appear in the INCI panel. Both are reproduced below, with the divergence disclosed.

Line C2. Classification by functional level
Level Materials Share of panel
Solvents & base 3 10.7%
Exfoliating acids 3 10.7%
Humectants & conditioning 2 7.1%
Surfactants & texture 9 32.1%
Preservatives & stabilisers 4 14.3%
Fragrance & sensory 3 10.7%
Botanicals & colorants 4 14.3%
Solvents / base: 3 Acids / exfoliants: 3 Humectants: 2 Surfactants: 9 Preservatives: 4 Fragrance: 3 Botanicals: 4
Chart 3 of 8. Functional level composition Share of the merged declared panel by functional level. Levels are assigned from the database function label with name overrides.
Botanicals Fragrance Preservatives Surfactants Humectants Acids / exfoliants Solvents / base 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 4 3 4 9 2 3 3
Chart 4 of 8. Count of materials by functional level Row counts behind the composition chart, in the same palette order.

The two charts above are the required level classification and count. The palette is applied in fixed order; the light-pink slice carries a dark outline so it stays visible on white.

What's inside

What's inside - 12 evaluated badge lines
Line C3. Claim matrix
Claim Holds Database note
Alcohol-free YES not stated
Paraben-free YES not stated
Silicone-free YES not stated
Sulfate-free YES not stated
Cruelty-free YES not stated
Pore-clogger-free YES not stated
Reef-safe YES not stated
EU-allergen-free NO not stated
Fragrance-free NO not stated
Oil-free NO not stated
Fungal-acne-safe NO not stated
Vegan NO not stated

A failing badge is printed by the database with a "Not " prefix. The prefix has been removed and the polarity stored in the Holds column. In particular, "Fragrance-free = NO" means the product is not fragrance free.

Claim holds: 7 Claim does not hold: 5
Chart 5 of 8. What's inside badge outcome Of 12 evaluated badges, 7 hold and 5 do not. A 'NO' means the product is not that thing.

Concerns, benefits and key groups

Concerns (4). May Worsen Rosacea, May Worsen Eczema, May Worsen Dryness, May Worsen Irritation.. These are ingredient-class warnings about what the formula contains, not a verdict on the product or on any individual user.

Benefits - 12 rows, strongest first
Line C4. Benefits
Benefit Ingredients delivering it
Hydrating 6
Brightening 5
Scar Healing 5
Redness Reducing 4
Barrier Repair 4
Reduces Large Pores 3
Anti-Aging 2
Reduces Irritation 2
Good For Oily Skin 2
Dark Spots 2
Skin Texture 2
Acne Fighting 1
Key ingredient groups and community votes
Line C5. Key groups
Group Ingredient count
Antioxidants 3
AHA 1
Retinoid 1
Vitamin C 1
Vitamin E 1
Exfoliators 1
Mixed / unrated Disliked Liked 0 3 6 9 12 15 5 13 10
Chart 6 of 8. Community ingredient votes Weak sentiment signal on individual ingredients, not a product verdict.

Declaration depth of the exfoliating acids

Line C6. Acid positions in the declared order
Row Material
2 Glycolic Acid

Read against the panel length of 28 rows, the acid block runs from row 2 to row 2. Position in a declared INCI is an ordering signal, not a concentration measurement; no percentage claim can be verified from an ordered list alone.

Ingredients list

Full declared panel - 28 rows in source order
  1. Water - Skin Conditioning
  2. Glycolic Acid - Buffering
  3. Glycerin - Humectant - comedogenic 0 / irritancy 0
  4. Sodium Hydroxide - Buffering
  5. Hamamelis Virginiana Water - Astringent
  6. Panthenol - Skin Conditioning - comedogenic 0 / irritancy 0
  7. Tocopheryl Acetate - Antioxidant - comedogenic 0 / irritancy 0
  8. 3-O-Ethyl Ascorbic Acid - Skin Conditioning
  9. Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract - Antimicrobial
  10. Chrysanthellum Indicum Extract - Skin Conditioning
  11. Menthol - Masking
  12. Menthyl Lactate - Masking
  13. Hydroxyethylcellulose - Emulsion Stabilising
  14. Propylene Glycol - Humectant - comedogenic 0 / irritancy 0
  15. Diazolidinyl Urea - Preservative
  16. PEG-50 Hydrogenated Castor Oil - Emulsifying
  17. Sodium Carbonate - Buffering
  18. Nonoxynol-12 - Emulsifying
  19. Polyglyceryl-10 Myristate - Skin Conditioning
  20. PEG-15 Glyceryl Stearate - Emulsifying
  21. Tricaprin - Masking
  22. Isononyl Isononanoate - Emollient
  23. Retinyl Palmitate - Skin Conditioning - comedogenic 1-3 / irritancy 1-3
  24. Butylene Glycol - Humectant - comedogenic 1 / irritancy 0
  25. Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate - Preservative
  26. PEG-35 Castor Oil - Emulsifying
  27. Hydrogenated Lecithin - Emulsifying
  28. BHT - Antioxidant

"EM" denotes an unrated cell, which is missing data rather than zero risk. A printed range such as 1-3 means sources disagree and is judged on its upper bound. No formula-wide average risk score is computed from the sparsely rated rows.

Retail declaration - 18 rows, consumer naming
  1. Distilled Water
  2. Glycolic Acid
  3. Witch Hazel
  4. Sodium Hydroxide
  5. Polysorbate 20
  6. Propanediol
  7. Vegetable Glycerin
  8. Vitamin B5
  9. Calendula Extract
  10. Green Tea Extract
  11. Allantoin
  12. Menthol
  13. Eucalyptus Oil
  14. Spearmint Oil
  15. Vitamin E
  16. I-Ascorbyl Palmitate (Vitamin C)
  17. Diazolidinyl Urea
  18. Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate

Database A rejection log. Searches were run at both product and brand level. The following near-misses were returned and explicitly rejected rather than substituted:

Line C7. Rejected database candidates
Candidate Dated Reason
Pharmlitalia Glycolic Acid Pads 35% 2026-09-21 Different brand; a 35% pad from an unrelated manufacturer.

[D] Product price

All-time tracker table, the required comparison bars, trend reading and derivations.

Line D1. All-time price history
Price type Lowest ever Highest ever Current Average
Amazon no data no data no data no data
3rd Party New $16.99 (Aug 20, 2024) $28.99 (Jul 08, 2025) $19.99 (Sep 22, 2026) $24.20
3rd Party Used no data no data no data no data

The column printed by the tracker as "Current +" carries a UI affordance, not a modified value; it is reported above as Current. Current is a dated last observation, not a live quote. It is dated Sep 22, 2026 (54 days before collection) and is therefore stale relative to the 2026-11-15 collection date. Empty rows are reported as no data rather than omitted. Amazon (first-party) and 3rd Party Used carry no data at all across the whole four-year record; the buy box is a marketplace offer.

Price at capture Subscribe & Save List price Lifetime average Current Highest ever Lowest ever 0 10 20 30 35.9476 $19.99 $16.99 $26.99 $24.20 $19.99 $28.99 $16.99
Chart 7 of 8. Price history table comparison All-time tracker figures beside the list price, the subscription price and the live buy-box value. USD per unit. Values are literal.

Comparison reading. The bars place the all-time extremes beside the current value, the lifetime average, the list price, the subscription price and the live buy box. This is the required bar comparison of the price history table.

16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Aug 2024 Jul 2025 Sep 2026 Nov 2026 capture $16.99 $28.99 $19.99 $19.99 Dated benchmark Lifetime average
Chart 8 of 8. Dated price benchmarks and lifetime average Only dated all-time extremes, the last tracked value and the capture reading are published. The connecting line is a visual guide, not an observed daily series; the dashed line is the lifetime average.

Dynamic trend analysis. The source publishes four summary values per price type with dates attached to three of them; it publishes no row-per-change series. The line therefore joins only dated all-time extremes, the last tracked value and the capture reading. The shape between those points is a visual guide, not an observed daily price path, and no interpolation is claimed. The dashed line is the $24.20 lifetime average, which the current value sits 17.4% below.

Line D2. Derived price metrics (all derivations)
Derivation Value
All-time spread (high - low) $12.00
Spread as share of low 70.6%
Current vs all-time low +17.7%
Current vs all-time high -31.0%
Current vs lifetime average -17.4%
Price at capture vs current tracker value +0.0%
Unit price at capture $0.33 per count (60 pads)
Subscribe & Save $16.99 (15% below the current price)

Freshness. Monitoring began Oct 28, 2022. The last update scan is reported as "2 months ago" and the last tracked value as "11 months ago"; both are relative labels that drift between fetches and are approximate when anchored to the collection date. Any use of the Current figure for a transaction should be preceded by a fresh quote.

Scope note. The summary block is all-time and returns the same values regardless of the chart window, so no period-specific low, high or average is presented. The tracker publishes no ingredient field and no sales-rank series; the only formula signal on that channel is the product title.


[E] Product images

Three retail photographs per row, reproduced from the listing gallery.

Line E1. Retail gallery - three images per row
Front of the NUVADERMIS jar: 'Exfoliating Glycolic Acid Pads - Face Care'.
Image 1. Front of the NUVADERMIS jar: 'Exfoliating Glycolic Acid Pads - Face Care'. Source: Amazon
Usage shot with the text 'Effective Exfoliation' and a textured pad against the cheek.
Image 2. Usage shot with the text 'Effective Exfoliation' and a textured pad against the cheek. Source: Amazon
Feature card naming Glycolic Acid, Green Tea Extract and Vitamins C & E.
Image 3. Feature card naming Glycolic Acid, Green Tea Extract and Vitamins C & E. Source: Amazon

Each row displays three retail product photographs side by side, each labelled Source: Amazon. No buyer photographs were exposed by the listing, so none are substituted.


[F] Methodology, confidence and limitations

How each figure was obtained, what is strong, and what is not available.

Line F1. Confidence ledger
Element Confidence Basis
Price at capture and unit price High Read from a US-address buy box in native USD.
Rating, count and star shares High Published aggregate on the retail page.
Aspect sentiment Medium Retailer-generated aggregation, not verbatim reviews.
Declared ingredient panel Medium 28-row full panel; single database, with channel divergence disclosed
Level classification Medium Derived taxonomy from function labels plus name overrides.
All-time price figures and dates High Transcribed verbatim from the tracker table.
Series shape between dated extremes Low No observation-level history is published.
Individual review text and buyer photos Not available Neither rendered on this SKU.

Limitations

  1. Single snapshot taken on 2026-11-15; rating counts, rank and prices move between captures.
  2. Star shares are published rounded values; a small bucket is not proof of zero ratings.
  3. No verbatim review bodies rendered, so no qualitative claim is attributed to a named buyer and no reviewer identity is reproduced.
  4. No buyer photographs were exposed; listing photography is not substituted for buyer imagery.
  5. One ingredient database returned zero rows for this SKU. Absence of a record is not evidence that the formula is safe, and no similar product was substituted.
  6. An ordered ingredient declaration cannot verify a concentration percentage; percentage claims are reported as claims, not measurements.
  7. The tracker summary is all-time only, its current value is stale, and there is no observation-level series behind the trend line.
  8. Community database ratings and badges are reference material from an aggregator, not a regulatory, dermatological or compliance conclusion.
  9. Relative freshness labels drift between fetches and are approximate.
  10. No collection links, file names or external addresses are reproduced in this report.

Editorial convention

Charts use a fixed ten-colour palette in the requested order on a white ground, with dark ink text, grey axis labels, a pale grid, and white tooltips outlined in the same pale grid colour. Each chart also carries a server-rendered static image so the figures remain visible when scripting is unavailable; where scripting is available the live chart replaces it at column width.