✨ Exfoliators & Peels

Peter Thomas Roth FIRMx Peeling Gel: the Flakes Are the Product

A peel with no acid in it. The roll of white flakes is cellulose, algin and carbomer, and the carton photograph declares nineteen materials where the listing text declares twenty-five.

A gel that peels without an acid. The visible roll of white flakes is cellulose, algin and carbomer balling up under the fingers, and the brand says so on the tube — “visibly exfoliates by rolling, lifting and sweeping away impurities.” What actually acts on skin is a three-row enzyme block at positions 7 to 9, led by a purified keratinase. It is a coherent, mild product. It is not a pore treatment, and it is priced at the top of its own eleven-year range.

Brand
Peter Thomas Roth
Format
One 100 ml / 3.4 fl oz tube
Buy box
$49.00 — $14.41 per fluid ounce
Rating
4.6 out of 5 from 3,256 ratings
Declared materials
25 in the listing text, 19 on the carton photo
Exfoliation route
Enzymatic at #7-9; mechanical pilling from cellulose at #3
Category rank
#38 in Facial Peels, #24,736 in Beauty & Personal Care
Value signal
Value for money: 51% positive over 96 mentions

01 Product information

One tube, 100 ml, sold and shipped by Amazon itself rather than a marketplace seller. The listing's specification block gives 3.4 fluid ounces and the pack prints 100 ml / 3.4 fl oz, so the $14.41 per ounce the page quotes is arithmetically correct. The tube is aluminium-look laminate with a black cap, and the carton carries the same copy as the tube.

FieldValue
BrandPeter Thomas Roth
Item formGel
Size3.4 fl oz (pack of 1), 100 ml
Skin type fieldDry
Product benefit fieldFor all skin types, this daily peeling gel exfoliates and helps decongest the look of skin without over-drying
Active Ingredients fieldhyaluronic_acid
Manufacturer / modelPeter Thomas Roth / 12-01-001
UPC843711257024, 670367000083, 827118806511
Dimensions1.9 × 1.9 × 6.8 in; 3.53 oz
AvailabilityIn stock, sold and shipped by Amazon.com
Buy box / Subscribe & Save$49.00 / $46.55 (5% off)
Best Sellers Rank#24,736 in Beauty & Personal Care; #38 in Facial Peels

How the brand describes it

“Beauty Product This item is not a tester Packaging may vary This product is for all skin types”

The listing's five bullet slots have collapsed into a single line of boilerplate, so the only selling copy a shopper sees is the title. That title is where the problem is: Removes Impurities, Unclogs Pores & Smooths Skin. The tube, which has more room to be careful, promises only that the gel exfoliates “by rolling, lifting and sweeping away impurities” and that “multi-action enzymes & cellulose” uncover a smoother-looking complexion. The pack is the more accurate document. Nothing in this formula is keratolytic, and two of its rows carry the highest comedogenicity scores in the panel.

02 Product rating and buyer sentiment

4.6 out of 5 from 3,256 ratings: 79% five stars, 10% four, 5% three, 2% two and 4% one. The shape is top-heavy but not clean — the one-star block is twice the size of the two-star block, which usually marks a specific recurring failure rather than general indifference. The aspect table below says which failure.

1 star 2 star 3 star 4 star 5 star 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 130 (4%) 65 (2%) 163 (5%) 326 (10%) 2,572 (79%)
Fig. 1 — 79% five stars, but a 4% one-star block is four times the two-star band.
Star bandRatingsShare
5 star2,57279%
4 star32610%
3 star1635%
2 star652%
1 star1304%

What buyers talk about

“Customers find the exfoliating gel effective and gentle, particularly noting it doesn't irritate sensitive skin and leaves it soft and smooth… However, opinions about value for money are mixed, with some saying it's worth the price while others disagree. Additionally, the product's durability receives mixed feedback, with some saying it lasts while others report flakes that aren't dead skin.”

618 mentions across eight aspects, and the split is almost too clean. Every performance aspect clears 85%: skin appearance 95%, ease of use 93%, skin feel 91%, effectiveness 90% over 267 mentions, gentleness 87%. Then value for money lands at 51% over 96 mentions — 49 positive, 47 negative, a dead heat on the single largest non-performance aspect. That is not a rounding artefact; it is half the buyers telling the other half they overpaid for 100 ml of gel. The summary also records buyers reporting “flakes that aren't dead skin”, which is the one place where the customer has independently identified the mechanism the ingredient list describes: cellulose, algin and carbomer pilling.

Skin Appearance Ease Of Use Skin Feel Effectiveness Gentle Everyday Use Duration Value For Money -100 -50 0 50 100 150 200 250 95% (38) 93% (15) 91% (110) 90% (267) 87% (46) 77% (22) 67% (24) 51% (96) Positive Negative
Fig. 2 — Eight aspects, 618 mentions. Value for money is the only aspect without a majority.
AspectMentionsPositiveNegativePositive share
Skin Appearance3836295%
Ease Of Use1514193%
Skin Feel1101001091%
Effectiveness2672412690%
Gentle4640687%
Everyday Use2217577%
Duration2416867%
Value For Money96494751%

03 Product ingredients

This product has three ingredient documents and they do not agree. The listing's text block declares 25 materials; the third carousel image is a photograph of an ingredients panel carrying 19; the independent database returns 25, matching the text block row for row. The photograph omits PEG-32, the keratinase, tetrasodium EDTA, algin, tromethamine, sodium chloride and calcium chloride, and it adds a plain Lactobacillus ferment that the text block does not have. Because the text block and the database agree independently, the 25-row version is treated as current here and the photographed carton as an earlier print. The divergence is disclosed rather than resolved, since both documents sit on the same product page.

Water & humectants 6 rows pH adjusters, chelator & electrolytes 6 rows Preservatives 4 rows Film-forming & pilling polymers 3 rows Enzymes & ferments 3 rows Emollient ester & botanical water 2 rows Colourant 1 row
Fig. 3 — Nine of the twenty-five rows are water, humectants, pH adjusters or salts; the exfoliating system is three rows.
Functional classRowsShare of declarationRange
Water & humectants624.0%#1, #2, #4, #6, #11, #12
pH adjusters, chelator & electrolytes624.0%#13-15, #18, #20, #21
Preservatives416.0%#10, #22, #23, #25
Film-forming & pilling polymers312.0%#3, #16, #17
Enzymes & ferments312.0%#7-9
Emollient ester & botanical water28.0%#5, #19
Colourant14.0%#24

Where each class sits

The architecture is unusual for a peel: the top three positions contain no exfoliant at all. Water, a PEG solvent and cellulose occupy 1 to 3, then a humectant, a bergamot water and sorbitol take 4 to 6, and only at 7 does the first active appear. The enzyme block is genuinely early — a purified keratinase, a pineapple extract and a pomegranate ferment at 7 to 9, ahead of the hyaluronate and glycerin that the listing calls its active. Everything from 13 to 21 is infrastructure: two pH adjusters, a chelator, two more pH adjusters, the two salts, and between them the algin and isopropyl myristate that the databases score worst. The functional centre of the product is therefore five rows wide, at positions 3, 7, 8, 9 and 16, and two of those five exist to make the gel ball up rather than to act on skin.

Colourant Emollient Enzyme Film former Preservative pH & salts Water / humectant 0 5 10 15 20 25 1 3 7 8 11 14 16 19 24
Fig. 4 — The three pilling polymers sit at 3, 16 and 17, so the gel that balls up is built in two stages around the actives.

Composition ladders

Positions 1–6, the vehicle 6 of 25 rows · water, PEG-32, cellulose, butylene glycol, bergamot water, sorbitol

Positions 7–12, the active core 6 of 25 rows · keratinase, pineapple, pomegranate ferment, radish ferment, hyaluronate, glycerin

Positions 13–21, infrastructure 9 of 25 rows · four pH adjusters or chelators, two salts, algin, carbomer, isopropyl myristate

Positions 22–25, preservation and colour 4 of 25 rows · three preservatives and mica

Chemical exfoliants, whole formula 0 of 25 rows · no AHA, no BHA, no PHA — citric acid at 14 is a pH adjuster

Claim audit

Six claims, and the audit splits three ways. The three the brand prints on the pack all hold, and one of them — cellulose smoothing the complexion when massaged — is a more honest description of pilling than most competitors risk. The gentleness claim holds in the sense that matters: no acid, no alcohol, no fragrance, which is why 87% of gentleness mentions are positive. The failure is the one claim the brand did not print. “Unclogs pores” is an Amazon title addition, and the formula argues against it at two positions: isopropyl myristate at 19 is scored comedogenic 5, algin at 16 comedogenic 4, and the database tags the product not pore-clogger-free. A buyer searching for a pore treatment is being routed to a product that a pore-prone buyer should read the label on first.

Enzymatic exfoliation Cellulose smoothing Glycerin and HA hydrate Gentle, for dry skin Unclogs pores 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 #7 #3 #11 #14 #19
Fig. 7 — The longer the bar, the deeper the supporting material; “unclogs pores” fails outright.
Claim as printedSubstantiated byRow #Verdict
“Pineapple and pomegranate enzymes”A purified keratinase at #7, plus pineapple fruit extract at #8 and a pomegranate ferment at #9#7-9Holds
“Cellulose: gently smooths complexion when massaged onto skin”Cellulose at #3, held in a gel with algin at #16 and carbomer at #17#3, #16, #17Holds — and explains the flakes
“Glycerin and hyaluronic acid hydrate and soothe”Sodium hyaluronate at #11 and glycerin at #12, behind four other humectants#11-12Holds
“Gentle exfoliant for dry, flaky skin” (title)No AHA and no BHA. The only acid is citric acid at #14, whose function is pH adjustment#14Partly, no chemical exfoliant
“Unclogs pores” (title)Nothing keratolytic. Isopropyl myristate at #19 is scored comedogenic 5 and algin at #16 comedogenic 4, and the database tags the product not pore-clogger-free#16, #19Fails
“For all skin types” (bullet)The two highest comedogenicity scores in the panel sit at #16 and #19; buyers with congested skin are the least well served#16, #19Partly

Full declaration

All 25 declared materials, in order
#MaterialFunctionAcneIrritancy
1Water/Aqua/EauSolvent-1
2PEG-32Solvent / humectant-1-2
3CelluloseViscosity control / abrasive-1
4Butylene GlycolSolvent / humectant10
5Citrus Aurantium Bergamia (Bergamot) Fruit WaterSkin conditioning-1
6SorbitolHumectant00
7R-Bacillus Licheniformis KeratinaseEnzyme-n/a
8Ananas Sativus (Pineapple) Fruit ExtractSkin conditioning / enzyme source-1
9Lactobacillus/Punica Granatum Fruit Ferment ExtractSkin conditioning / ferment-1
10Leuconostoc/Radish Root Ferment FiltratePreservative / antimicrobial-1
11Sodium HyaluronateHumectant00
12GlycerinHumectant00
13Sodium HydroxidepH adjuster-1-4
14Citric AcidpH adjuster-1-2
15Tetrasodium EDTAChelator-2
16AlginViscosity control / film former44
17CarbomerViscosity control / film former11
18TromethaminepH adjuster-1-3
19Isopropyl MyristateEmollient ester / solvent53
20Sodium ChlorideViscosity control / electrolyte0-3-
21Calcium ChlorideViscosity control / astringent-1
22Potassium SorbatePreservative-2
23Sodium BenzoatePreservative-1-2
24MicaPigment-1
25PhenoxyethanolPreservative-2-4

Functions and scores are the second database's readings. Two materials have no score: the keratinase is too new to be indexed (“n/a” is a gap, not a zero) and sodium chloride is scored only for acne. The photographed carton panel is transcribed in section 05. Note also that the listing's bullet block is boilerplate and contains no ingredient copy at all, so there is no third textual declaration to break the tie.

04 Product price

Unlike most listings in this series, this one has a first-party series: Amazon has sold the product itself for most of the record, and the Amazon and third-party channels are reported separately. Both currently read $49.00. The Amazon value is dated 04 November 2026 and the third-party value 05 November 2026, so neither is stale by more than ten days.

Price typeLowest everHighest everCurrentAverage
Amazon (first party)$24.00 (Dec 01, 2019)$49.00 (Dec 17, 2024)$49.00 (Nov 04, 2026)$41.64
3rd party new$24.00 (Dec 12, 2016)$49.00 (Oct 09, 2026)$49.00 (Nov 05, 2026)$32.47
3rd party used————
Lowest ever, both channels 3rd party average Amazon average Subscribe and Save Tracker list price Current = highest ever 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 $24.00 $32.47 $41.64 $46.55 $48.00 $49.00
Fig. 5 — Six levels from an eleven-year record. The current price is also the all-time high on both channels.

Distance from today's price

The current price is also the all-time high on both channels — and the high is not a 2018 scarcity print this time, it is a level reached in December 2024 and again in October 2026. That changes how the number should be read: $49.00 is not an outlier, it is where the product has settled. Against the tracker's $48.00 list price it is 2.1% over; against the Amazon eleven-year average of $41.64 it is 17.7% over; against the third-party average of $32.47 it is 50.9% over. The low of $24.00 is exactly half of today's price and dates to 2019 on the first-party channel.

Tracker list price Subscribe and Save Amazon average 3rd party average Lowest ever 0% 30% 60% 90% 120% 142% +2.1% +5.3% +17.7% +50.9% +104.2% 0
Fig. 6 — Today's $49.00 set against each reference level.
Reference levelValueDifference vs todayPercent
Tracker list price$48.00+$1.00+2.1%
Subscribe & Save$46.55+$2.45+5.3%
Amazon average$41.64+$7.36+17.7%
3rd party average$32.47+$16.53+50.9%
Lowest ever (Dec 2019)$24.00+$25.00+104.2%

At $14.41 per fluid ounce this is the most expensive product in this batch by a wide margin, and the value-for-money aspect is the only one where buyers split evenly. There is a structural reason the two channels diverge so far on average: the third-party average of $32.47 includes years when marketplace sellers undercut the brand, while the Amazon series only exists where Amazon itself held the buy box. Reading the $32.47 as “the real price” would understate what a shopper actually pays today, and reading the $49.00 as permanent would ignore that it was $24.00 seven years ago. The honest statement is the narrow one: the product is at its ceiling, the ceiling has held since December 2024, and the Subscribe & Save rate of $46.55 is the only discount available.

05 Product images

Three plates. The first is the tube face, which prints the mechanism in the brand's own words: visibly exfoliates by rolling, lifting & sweeping away impurities when massaged onto skin. The second is the tube in its carton. The third is the one that matters for this report — a photograph of an ingredients panel that declares 19 materials where the listing's text block declares 25. The seven it omits and the one it adds are listed in section 03. A shopper who reads only the images and a shopper who reads only the text are looking at two different formulas.

Product photograph 1
Plate 1 · Source: Amazon
Product photograph 2
Plate 2 · Source: Amazon
Product photograph 3
Plate 3 · Source: Amazon

Photographs are the listing's own carousel assets, reproduced unmodified. The carton panel photographed in plate 3 reads: water/aqua/eau, cellulose, butylene glycol, citrus aurantium bergamia fruit water, sorbitol, ananas sativus fruit extract, lactobacillus/punica granatum fruit ferment extract, leuconostoc/radish root ferment filtrate, lactobacillus ferment, sodium hyaluronate, glycerin, citric acid, mica, sodium hydroxide, sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, isopropyl myristate, carbomer, phenoxyethanol.

06 Method, sources and limits

Four documents feed this report and they disagree with each other, which is the report's main subject. They carry different weight.

  • The product record, rating histogram, review-aspect table and images come from the listing as rendered for a US delivery address on 14 November 2026.
  • The 25-row declaration is the listing's own ingredients block. The 19-row declaration is transcribed from the third carousel image of the same page.
  • The independent database returns 25 rows and agrees with the text block row for row; it also supplies the acne and irritancy scores used in the full-declaration table.
  • The price history is the tracker's all-time record with the window set to the full life of the record, so the low and high are lifetime figures and are labelled as such.
  • Buyer sentiment is the listing's own aspect summary, quoted rather than re-derived.

What this report cannot tell you

  • No individual review text was retrievable, so every sentiment statement is aggregate and no reviewer is quoted or identifiable.
  • The 19-row carton photograph and the 25-row text block cannot both describe the tube on sale. The text block is treated as current only because it matches the database independently; that is an inference, not a stated fact, and a buyer could receive either formula.
  • Two materials have no database score, so the “worst in panel” statements refer only to scored rows.
  • Concentration is not published. Position orders materials by amount descending and says nothing about the ratio between neighbours.
  • The pilling mechanism is inferred from the presence of three film-forming polymers at positions 3, 16 and 17 and from buyers describing flakes; it was not verified by testing the product.

Collected 14 November 2026. Prices in US dollars, no conversion applied. The product was not purchased or tested; every statement is a reading of published material.